Josie Romero: daughter, sister, trans child

July 25, 2010

The recent New York Times article, When to Out a Transgendered Dater?, written by a cis man posing as an ethicist, was notable more for its display of blatant cisupremacism and noxious subtext of anti trans sentiment than for answering its own question in any useful way. Thankfully, it’s been thoroughly and deservedly deconstructed in numerous responses (see Questioning Transphobia, The Bay Area Reporter, Feministing and Bilerico, to name but a few).

In the light of that unnecessary reminder that many cis people will always make it about them, it’s a real breath of fresh air to read about two cis parents, Venessia and Joseph Romero, who are as open, supportive and loving as any child could wish for. Four years ago they found that their elder daughter Josie is transgender and since then, according to the Arizona Daily Star (see also the site’s health blog), have worked hard to follow her lead.

And Josie is not only adamant that she’s a girl, but also that she’s transgender. She doesn’t want to hide who she is, and her family says they respect and support that. Telling her story validates her, her mother says.

“Josie is very proud of who she is,” Venessia says. “Why go through life with a secret? Where’s the health in that? There should be no shame.”

[...]

“Josie will change her mind on many issues in her life. Halfway through grad school she may switch her major,” Venessia says. “But her blood type will never change, and she’ll always be female. All through Josie’s life she has persistently and consistently identified as female. Josie is a girl, has always been a girl, and will grow up to become a woman. That is just part of who she is.”

Josie Romero (image via Mamta Popat/Arizona Daily Star)

Needless to say, the Romero family has received a lot of criticism, not least for being the focus of a significant amount of media attention.

A year ago, National Geographic contacted TransYouth Family Allies seeking a family with a transgender child, and the group contacted the Romeros. Venessia says the family gave it a lot of thought, including talking with Josie. Ultimately, they decided it would be a good idea and other media appearances soon followed.

“This world isn’t going to change on its own,” Venessia says as Josie and sister Jade, adopted from China when she was 2 and Josie was 3, ride their pink and purple bikes. “I don’t want her growing into a world that isn’t ready for her.”

Which, to me, is the heart of the matter. Articles like the NYT piece I mentioned above have only one purpose: to reinforce the ciscentric (and cissupremacist) values of a world which is transphobic by default. All anti trans rhetoric is fundamentally and intractably aimed at upholding the essentially (and essentialist) transphobic belief that trans people simply shouldn’t exist. As Alison Davison, coordinator of the Southern Arizona Gender Alliance points out, in the debate about whether TS/TG people should be ‘out’:

Many transgender folks prefer to live what we call a ‘stealth’ existence.

If they are transsexual, they will go through the stages of transition and often do their best to quietly blend in. There are philosophical and political discussions about the importance of being ‘out.’

Personally, I think there is strength in being out and public. I think the rest of society needs to see faces and hear stories of transgender people so they can develop greater understanding and compassion.

Whilst I’m broadly in agreement with this, I doubt that any cis person can ever truly understand our experiences of being trans; however, it’s true that a little more acceptance wouldn’t go amiss. And a useful place to start for cis people who want to show solidarity with, and support for, our communities would be to actually listen to us with the same degree of care and attention as Venessia and Joseph Romero have shown for Josie. If we were able to feel safe enough around cis people that mentioning, or not, that we’re trans wouldn’t be putting our lives at risk whether we self-disclose, or not – then just maybe the world could take another small step towards being a better place for all of us.

—————

Edited to add: There are a couple of YouTube videos of Tyra Banks’ interview with Josie and her family, televised in January 2010. Despite the poor quality of sound and images, either is well worth taking 10 minutes to watch. Here are the links:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OB-L_HkW_eI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nQpaL9sPYA

—————

Cross-posted at Questioning Transphobia

About these ads

8 Responses to “Josie Romero: daughter, sister, trans child”

  1. earwicga Says:

    Thanks for highlighting Josie. I’ve read of this family and wish all trans children could belong to families like this.

    Just wanted to add though, I found the Tyra Banks’ show pretty problematic and thought Tyra was very inappropriate and your post had prompted me to google round and I found this GLAAD response on which Venessia (I assume it’s her) responds.

    And I suppose it’s worth mentioning that Josie may not always identify as a girl as it has been said that as many as 80% of apparent (as opposed to non-apparent) trans children lose their ‘gender dysphoria’ at Tanner stage 1 puberty. I’ve not seen a break down of whether these children feel it easier to conform to their ascribed gender than brave it through the disgusting discrimination thrown at trans people,. I don’t think there have been any follow up studies done.

    But regardless it is essential that children be supported for who they are, not what may or may not happen in the future.

  2. Helen G Says:

    Thanks; I’ve updated my QT crosspost accordingly.

    It’s interesting that you seem to have had such a strong negative reaction to both the show and its presenter whereas I notice that, depite its stated reservations, GLAAD felt that the broadcast brought the topic of trans children to daytime TV in a mostly fair and respectful manner.

    As to how many trans children may or may not go on to fully transition (medically, surgically, socially, legally), although it’s an interesting subject, it’s beyond the scope of my post, in which I was thinking more about cis society’s acceptance (or not) of trans children as they live out their childhood years in an intrinsically transphobic society. Perhaps I shall write more on the subject later.

  3. Ruth Says:

    Glad she has a supportive and close family. I hope she does grow into a world that’s ready for her.

  4. earwicga Says:

    I didn’t have a negative reaction to Josie and her family.

    I felt that Tyra (and her writers) were the problem. A cis child wouldn’t be asked intrusive questions about their genitals but it is considered ok to ask a trans child? No it isn’t. Plus Tyra seemed to hold sexist views i.e. girls like skirts and pink which has nothing to do with trans. Also annoyed me when they brought on another trans child and implied that it was a right proper treat for Josie – woo hoo, we have a special surprise for you, here is another child just like you so you are sure to get on. Just as stupid as it would be if the world was majority trans and I was on a show and the presenter said, woo hoo, we have a special surprise for you, here is a cis woman called dittany and you are sure to get on because you are both cis. It was such a shame that they had perfectly ordinary people on the show and they were treated in an extraordinary way. No need to do that.

  5. Lisa Harney Says:

    earwicga,

    There was an article about trans children in Atlantic Monthly last year that pointed out that most of the children who start transition don’t back down. I’m not sure when puberty blockers are typically started, though, whether it’s before or after.

    I do think that for various reasons that studies about children and cross-gender identification tend to be biased in a ciscentric way. One study I can think of (was it Money or Green?) followed up with trans kids until they were 20 or so? They weren’t treated and who knows how much cissexism they internalized and how many transitioned in their late 20s, 30s, or later?

  6. earwicga Says:

    Thanks Lisa – I’ll have a look for the Atlantic article. And that’s what I meant really, of the 80% how many really are cis or remain trans and (hopefully) transition later.

    Bit off-topic really, but I read this last night on sexual orientation and studies and felt it applies equally to trans gender http://www.bekhsoos.com/web/2010/07/choice-how-or-why/

  7. earwicga Says:

    Lisa – do you meant the Hanna Rosin piece? http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/11/a-boy-apos-s-life/7059/1/ It covers all the usual suspects, Money, Green, Zucker (spit).


Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 59 other followers

%d bloggers like this: